
D.C. police chief grilled on shooting
D.C. police chief grilled on shooting
Stands by deadly use of force against unarmed mom
Capitol Hill Police Chief Kim C. Dine told a congressional hearing Monday his department made the right call when officers gunned down an unarmed mother with her baby in tow.
The killing of Miriam Carey Oct. 3 was the subject of questioning by the House Appropriations Committee – a shooting for which the department has still refused to release to the public a full report.
Dine called the high-speed car chase that started at the White House and ended with the Capitol under lockdown a “very, very quick, very fluid set of circumstances.”
Dine said he could not offer details on any possible criminal charges that officers might face as a result of the incident, which is still under investigation by the Metropolitan Police Department and the U.S. attorney for the District of Columbia. Valerie Carey, sister of the victim, has also filed a wrongful death claim against the Capitol Police, as well as the Uniformed Division of the U.S. Secret Service, seeking $75 million in compensation.
“These officers are out there every day putting their lives on the line and they have to make split-second decisions, and it’s easy for any one of us to obviously sit here and second guess them,” but even case law doesn’t allow for that, Dine told the committee.
Rep. James P. Moran, D-Va., challenged Dine to weigh in on whether, given that Carey was unarmed and had a child on board, it might have been a better idea to shoot at the car’s tires, rather than at her body.
“There’s a lot of opinions out there but most of them are wrong and uneducated,” Dine shot back.
Dine told the panel considering his agency’s fiscal 2015 budget request that the department has begun to “analyze and dissect” other aspects of the shooting, including perimeter security and communication issues.
Rep. Debbie Wasserman Schultz, D-Fla., asked if the radio system had hindered the department’s response. She said some officers were concerned that radios in use at the time were not capable of communicating with Secret Service agents.
Dine assured her that even though the department’s new radio system was not yet in use, communication was possible via two emergency channels and a mutual aid radio system. He also said the new radio system, implemented in late February had “critically enhanced” communication.
“We’re in a much better place than we were before,” he said.
Asked if he was happy with officer conduct and the outcome of the incident, Dine said, “Well, I’m never happy when someone dies.”
Five days after the shooting death of Carey, Sen. Susan Collins, R-Maine, expressed alarm that a faulty radio system might have been an issue.
“If these communication failures are in fact accurate, it is extremely concerning that this problem still has not been resolved after years of experience with such situations, as well as billions of dollars spent to resolve our weaknesses in interoperable communications systems,” said the former chairwoman and ranking member of the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee.
But Valarie Carey, a former New York Police Department sergeant and sister of the victim, told WND problems she believes a bigger issue was inexperience on the part of the officers who killed Miriam.
Valarie was concerned officers may have panicked, and she suggested they might not have ever experienced such a situation.
“The more experienced an officer is, the better equipped that officer is to address the situation, even if there had been a problem with radio contact,” she said. “If someone can’t decide when to take someone’s life, they should not be put in that position.”
At the end of January, attorney Eric Sanders informed WND he had filed the multi-million dollar claim against the U.S., the uniformed division of the U.S. Secret Service and the U.S. Capitol Police for “numerous intentional, grossly negligent and reckless actions of police officers, supervisors, managers and other related employees.”
Sanders said that after months of waiting for the release of the official investigation and after an exhaustive review of all publicly available data, the Carey family has concluded the shooting was not justified.
The suit maintains Carey was still alive after she was shot numerous times by officers and then taken to a hospital, where she was pronounced dead.
Carey was mortally wounded by gunfire during the chase, according to the suit. But, out of panic, she continued driving until she finally came to a stop and was taken from her car, a few blocks away from the initial shooting.
The suit said the incident began because Carey “mistakenly drove past the first guard post at the White House entrance because the entrance was negligently maintained, covered and supervised by police officers, supervisors, managers” and others, and then tried to make a lawful U-turn to leave.
However, according to the claim, “for some inexplicable reason,” instead of simply allowing Carey to leave, a police officer “without provocation or legal justification, inconsistent with his or her police training, negligently and recklessly threw a bicycle rack at the vehicle, striking it.”
The suit goes on to maintain that Carey had not violated any law, and, therefore, police had “no legal basis to stop her or use any amount of physical force against her.”
Sanders claims officers endangered Carey’s safety, not the other way around. He contends the ensuing car chase also endangered the public, outweighing “the benefit of investigating a harmless mistaken entrance through the White House entrance gate.”
Sanders has filed the wrongful death claim on behalf of Carey’s mother, Idealla, Carey’s estate and her 1-year-old daughter, who was in the backseat of the car during the chase and, apparently, during the shooting. The suit will seek $25 million for each claimant. Sanders said the suit is to compensate the family for their “great loss of a daughter, mother, friend and confidant.” But he insists the case is about more than the death of just one woman. He says it represents a threat to the rights of all Americans.
“Somehow, the Bill of Rights did not apply to Miriam. Miriam’s life did not seem to be so important. Thus far, Miriam’s death is being treated as simple collateral damage in the government’s zeal to protect itself from terrorism,” said Sanders.
He said that zeal should not eclipse the importance of human life.
“The framers of the United States Constitution fought for, died for and demanded it. We should expect no different in today’s society either,” he said.
Sanders, a former New York Police Department officer, has told WND numerous reasons why he believes officers should never have shot at Carey.
•Media reports claimed Carey tried to ram a White House gate or barrier with her car, but the initial police report did not mention an attempt to ram anything;
•The police report said Carey tried to make a U-turn after arriving at a White House checkpoint;
•She apparently broke no laws until fleeing after being confronted by heavily armed guards;
•Police justified the shooting out of fear Carey might be a terrorist, but Sanders pointed out, if officers feared Carey had a bomb, that would be reason not to shoot at her;
•Additionally, WND found information that officers would have known within minutes that Carey was not a terrorism threat;
•Sanders and law enforcement experts also told WND the policy of most major police departments is to never shoot at moving vehicles;
•Non-lethal means, such as tire spikes, apparently were not used to try to stop the car.
•Non-lethal means, such as pepper spray or a Taser, apparently were not used to subdue Carey before officers shot her to death;
•Video showed officers shooting at Carey in a crowded public space at least seven times after officers inexplicably failed to block her car at a traffic circle.
Read more at http://www.wnd.com/2014/03/d-c-police-chief-grilled-on-shooting/#UIK5tYf70UV27MPA.99