Quebec’s social programs can’t survive as is
Quebec’s social programs can’t survive as is. Why can’t Quebecers admit this?
Late last month, weekend, 25-year-old Quebec director Xavier Dolan took home the Cannes jury prize for his movie Mommy, with French cinema legend Jean-Luc Godard. No small feat indeed as more experienced Canadian filmmakers David Cronenberg and Atom Egoyan were also in the running. Shortly thereafter, in Nuremberg, Germany, Quebec tennis player Eugénie Bouchard won her first WTA title, which places her firmly in the major leagues.
Quebec has a lot to be proud of. Its sons and daughters, adoptive or native born, shine on many of the world’s stages. So why in heaven’s name are we so lousy at fixing the province’s finances?
Over the years, Quebec has dug itself deep in the hole: To start with, there’s the $3.1-billion deficit and a $266-billion debt load. The per capita public spending and spending on government programs are the highest in Canada. And so is the tax burden. The Parti Québécois government that was voted out of office on April 7 was still spending and borrowing like there’s no tomorrow. To cap it off, last year, Quebec received $16-billion more from the federal government than it sent to Ottawa. All this, in the name of protecting the Quebec model.
Philippe Couillard’s newly-elected Liberals will try once again to reform the Quebec social democratic model. In his inaugural speech at the National Assembly, last Thursday, the message was clear: Brace yourselves, as this will hurt. The Quebec government needs fixing or the province will hit the wall.
Quebecers have heard this before, and recently. Back in 2003, premier Jean Charest promised to “re-engineer” the state; his efforts lasted about six months. The unions led a massive movement against the Liberal government and Charest backed down. Indeed, the only government that succeeded in taming the deficit beast was the Parti Québécois under Lucien Bouchard, way back in the mid-Nineties. The exercise was brutal and resulted in more nurses and doctors taking early retirement than necessary, creating a severe shortage that still plagues our health-care system today, and left a bad taste in Quebecers’ mouthes.
The province does not have a critical mass of right-wing thinkers and voters. There’s very little difference between the way the Liberals, arguably centre-right, manage Quebec’s affairs and the centre-left Parti Québécois’s way of governing. The truth is, a majority of Quebecers prefer social democracy to a free market economy.
Philippe Couillard made all the right noises in his speech, but he also left out any references to getting rid of the Quebec model. After programs are reviewed and the cutting is done, he promises more government involvement to stimulate the economy
